Before I start, can I just say I was so happy with all the fantastic comments on my angry post about unemployment the other day. I was half expecting to get comments along the lines of ‘suck it up, Emily’ so it was great to hear that other people are or have been in the same boat, and that I’m not just being pathetic. So thanks, you lovely humans!
There were a few things about Caitlin Moran’s ‘How To Be A Woman’ that I didn’t like-
1) It seemed very sloppy in parts. The sentence structure and word choices were sometimes very poor, giving the impression that it had been thrown together hastily and not checked very thoroughly. For example, Lady GaGa ‘slowing bleeding to death’ on page 257. Should that not be slowly? (Correct me if I’m wrong.)
2) Caps lock, punctuation, brackets. Just stop.
3) Occasionally it seemed a lot like an angry, excited blog post. I suppose, given that it is classed as ‘part memoir, part rant’ I should have expected this. I enjoy reading and writing angry, excited blog posts but I felt like it didn’t work as well in a book. Maybe I’m just old-fashioned, though.
Now that’s over with, I can begin to gush. I loved this book! I actually bought it from Waterstones (something I never do) and fully intended to put it to one side and read it when I was finished with other books. I made the mistake, though, of reading the first page, and then I couldn’t stop. Despite what I said above, I really enjoyed Moran’s wr
iting style. It seemed like I was personally being told a story by a very funny friend. The stories that involved her sister Caz were particularly hilarious – from “if you’re going to try and tell me how much you enjoy wanking” to drinking cystitis medicine and vodka from a mug.
The bad reviews of it that I’ve read, specifically on Goodreads, seem to have a problem with the fact that it is not a) an actual rulebook on how to be a woman or b) a serious, intellectual, sociological feminist study. I didn’t expect it to be either of these things, and it wasn’t, and all the better for it. I didn’t want to read either of these things (not today, anyway: I have a book called ‘Rules for a Lady’, and I’ve read a decent amount of ~serious feminist books~) and I was glad that it was a fairly light-hearted and relatable account of the things that normal women have to put up with on a day-to-day basis, and reasons why it is, as Moran says, “total fucking bullshit.” Rather than writing about the ethics and principles of abortion, she writes about her own abortion. Rather than discussing weddings in an abstract way, Moran discusses her own wedding.
Here is my favourite quote from the book-
These days, however, I am much calmer – since I realised that it’s technically impossible for a woman to argue against feminism. Without feminism, you wouldn’t be allowed to have a debate on women’s place in society. You’d be too busy giving birth on the kitchen floor – biting down on a wooden spoon, so as not to disturb the men’s card game – before going back to quick-liming the dunny. This is why those female columnists in the Daily Mail – giving daily wail against feminism – amuse me. They paid you £1,600 for that, dear, I think. And I bet it’s going in your bank account, and not your husband’s. The more women argue loudly, against feminism, the more they both prove it exists and that they enjoy its hard-won privileges.
October 17, 2011 at 10:48 pm
I loved this book too! I read it on holiday – it’s perfect holiday reading actually.
I found myself laughing out loud several times which is always a good :-)
It’s a fantastic book to give to people who feel that feminism is no longer relevant (ignorant people) as it really illustrates how the modern western world is still in severe need of equalizing! Not for the fainthearted though, particularly the chapter on her childbirth experience… I confess I just skimmed that part!
I agree with the sloppiness part, although I think it might be more of a poor editing job.
Great review :-)
October 18, 2011 at 12:54 pm
It was really funny! Even when she was discussing unhappy relationships, difficult births and abortions there were still little bits that made me snort with laughter.
Too many people think that feminism has done all it can, and that equality has been achieved, when this is completely and utterly not the case. I hope that this book helps to make it OK to say you’re a feminist these days. The fact that only 29% of American women + 42% of English women would say they were is really awful! I guess too many people still think it means you’re a humourless man-hater.
The childbirth chapter was pretty harrowing! Though as I’m pretty scared of childbirth + motherhood it didn’t really convince me to have any kids quite yet haha.
True, it probably is a poor editing job. I got the feeling that everyone was in a hurry to get it printed and published, which I can understand, but there were some sentences that just didn’t make a lot of sense.
Thanks :)
October 18, 2011 at 9:32 pm
Hmm, this sounds interesting. I’m trying to decide if it would be my kind of book or not, as the blog-style rant kinda threw me off–I mean, I love reading rants on blogs, I AM a blogger(-ish) after all, but I can see that in book-form it might get old. That said, I usually like a well-done memoir, typos/grammatical errors aside.
Pingback: 2011: Books « What Emily Did Next